
How to Tell If Your Lock Was Picked: What Locksmiths Check
You usually cannot tell from the outside. Picking leaves its clearest marks inside the cylinder, on the pins, and those only show up when a locksmith takes the cylinder apart and looks under magnification. The scratches you can see around the keyway are almost always from your own keys, years of them.
That is the short version. The longer one covers what is worth checking yourself, what points to an ordinary explanation instead, and what to do when you cannot rule it out, which is usually the cheapest part of the whole problem.
What you can and cannot see from the outside
Start with the lock face, in good light, before anyone touches it.
Normal wear looks like this. Fine scratches fanning out around the keyway, a polished ring where the key and the keychain rub, a dull finish on the face. Every lock that gets used every day looks like this, and it means nothing.
Worth a second look. Fresh, bright scratches at the very edges of the keyway that are clearly newer than the wear around them. Scrape marks or dents on the face of the cylinder. A cylinder that now sits crooked, spins, or has a gap around it. Fresh pry marks on the door edge or the frame near the bolt.
What it proves. Very little on its own. Bright scratches can come from a new key copy with rough edges, a guest using the wrong key, or a keychain. Pry marks and a loose cylinder point to force, not picking, and force is a different and more common story.
What the outside cannot show you is whether the pins inside were manipulated. That needs the cylinder out of the door.
What a locksmith sees when the cylinder comes apart
A key lifts each pin from the bottom, in the same place, every time. Tools work differently, and under magnification they can leave fine marks a key does not: scratches on the pins and inside the plug in places your key never touches. A clean cylinder with only key wear is reassuring. Clear tool marks are not proof of a break-in, but they are worth noting in writing.
A working locksmith can tell you whether a cylinder shows obvious tool marks. Proving how a lock was defeated, the kind of examination an insurer or a court sometimes asks for, is a forensic specialty done under a microscope, with the cylinder preserved as evidence. If you think it might come to that, do not have the lock rekeyed or replaced until you know who needs to examine it.
The ordinary explanations people mistake for picking
Most "my lock has been tampered with" calls turn out to be one of these.
- The key started sticking. Worn pins, a worn key, a badly cut copy, or grit in the keyway. Locks wear out from the inside, and it feels sudden even when it is not.
- The bolt does not throw all the way. The door has shifted and the bolt is rubbing the strike. Common after a season change, and covered in the guide to an apartment door that will not lock.
- The lock feels gritty or stiff in winter. Cold and moisture, not a burglar. The frozen lock guide covers what helps and what makes it worse.
- The lock was left unlocked. It happens to everyone. A door that pulls shut on a spring latch is not locked unless the deadbolt was thrown.
- Someone used a key. The most common way in without damage is a real key: a lost set, an old copy, a former roommate, a contractor, a dog walker. A key leaves no marks at all.
That last one matters most, because it changes what you should do next.
How entries actually happen
The best national data is old but consistent. In the Bureau of Justice Statistics study of household burglaries from 2003 to 2007, the largest group, about 1.9 million a year out of 3.7 million, was "unlawful entry," a burglary committed "even though no force was used to gain entry." In 40% of unlawful entries into homes where nobody was in, the way in was an unlocked door or window. A picked lock or window accounted for 4.1% of unlawful entries when nobody was home and 2.2% when someone was, which works out to under 2% of all household burglaries. A later BJS report covering 1994 to 2011 found the same pattern: entry without force was the largest category every year.
Burglary in New York City has also been falling. The NYPD counted 12,777 burglaries in 2025, down from 13,301 the year before.
The practical reading for a New York apartment: if someone got in and nothing was forced, a key is a likelier explanation than a picked lock. Either way, the fix is the same.
When you cannot rule it out: rekey
You do not need to prove how someone got in to close the door on it. A rekey changes the pins inside your existing cylinders so a new key works and every old key, copy or borrowed key stops working. On a standard apartment door with a knob and a deadbolt, rekeying runs $85 to $150. The service call depends on the hour, $60 from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., so if the door is secure tonight, a morning visit costs less.
Rekeying answers the key question. It does not change how resistant the cylinder is to manipulation, because it is the same cylinder with new pins. If that worries you, the step up is a high-security cylinder, $225 to $500 per opening. UL 437, the Underwriters Laboratories standard high-security cylinders are listed to, includes attack tests such as picking and drilling, and the keys for those systems are copied only through authorized dealers. Whether your door needs one is a judgment for someone standing in front of it, and the post on whether you need high-security locks gives an honest answer for most apartments.
If you think someone was inside
Do these in order, and keep it calm.
- If the door is open or you hear someone, do not go in. Call 911 from outside.
- Photograph before you touch. The lock face, the door edge, the frame, the strike plate, anything moved inside.
- Report it. A police report matters for an insurance claim and for the building's records. The after-break-in checklist covers which reports to file and in what order.
- Tell the building. In a rental or co-op, management needs to know, and they know who else holds keys: the super, staff, a previous tenant whose keys were never collected.
- Rekey, or preserve the cylinder. Rekey the same day unless an insurer or detective wants the cylinder examined first. If they do, have the locksmith replace the cylinder and hand you the old one untouched.
Smart locks keep a better record than metal ones
If your door has a smart lock, check its activity log before anything else. Most keep a history of every unlock, by code, by app user or by key, and that log answers the question faster than any scratch. Look for codes you forgot you shared, users you never removed, and unlocks at hours nobody was home. Then delete old codes and users. That is free, and it closes the door on most of the possibilities a smart lock has.
A mechanical key override on a smart lock is still a pin-tumbler cylinder, so the advice above applies to it too.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can police tell if a lock was picked? A police report usually records whether there were signs of forced entry. A picked lock rarely shows any from the outside, so the report may say no forced entry. Determining whether a cylinder was manipulated takes a forensic examination of the pins, which is a specialist job.
What does a picked lock look like? From the outside, usually like any other lock. If anything shows, it is fresh scratches at the edges of the keyway that are newer than the surrounding wear. The real evidence is inside, on the pins, and needs the cylinder taken apart.
Will rekeying stop someone who picked my lock? Rekeying stops every old key from working, which covers the likeliest way someone got in without force. It does not make the cylinder harder to manipulate. For that, the upgrade is a high-security cylinder tested to UL 437.
Should I rekey or replace the lock after suspected tampering? Rekey if the lock works well and nothing was forced. Replace it if the cylinder is damaged, loose or worn, or if you want a high-security upgrade. Preserve the old cylinder if an insurer or detective may want to examine it.
How much does it cost to rekey after a suspected break-in? A standard apartment door with a knob and a deadbolt is $85 to $150 to rekey, plus a service call of $60 during business hours, $90 in the evening and $125 overnight.
Need Expert Help?
If you have questions about any of the security solutions discussed in this article, our team is ready to provide expert guidance.
Call us at (844) 912-1908 for a free consultation or to schedule a service.